A fixed deadline. The y2k problem is about an absolutely fixed deadline. There has never been a more fixed deadline in recorded history. Will the world meet it? I don't think so.
It's not just a question of getting a single computer system compliant. It's a question of getting all computers that presently share data with each other compliant in such a way that they still interact with each other without corrupting each other's data. I say this is impossible. I say it is too late for every bank's computer to be fixed in such a way that its fix will correspond with all the other repaired computers.
When I say "system," I mean up to three things: (1) the system of programs that constitutes one business's computerized operations; (2) the system of computerized communications that enables the organization to communicate by computer to other computers; (3) the world economy. We have yet to see any Fortune 500 company announce: "Our firm is fully Year-2000 compliant at the present time." I am arguing that we will not see any industry announce: "Our members are fully Year 2000-compliant today as individual firms and as participants in this industry." I am surely arguing that the following sentence will not be added to the previous ones: "And so are our members' banks."
If the world economy can be saved, shouldn't there first be at least ONE large firm and ONE major government that is fully compliant? Is that too much to ask? I say, "Assume the worst until there is at least one major success story in business and one in government." For saying this in public, I am dismissed as an apocalyptic fanatic.
Remember, it's possible to be a reality-denying fanatic, too. The lung cancer victim who says he has bronchitis is a reality-denying fanatic. He will be dead soon, no matter what he believes.
By the very nature of the problem, I am saying that it is indeed too late. The Millennium Bug will bite. As to how hard it will bite any of us, I cannot say. But it will bite the system, i.e., the Western economy in the broadest sense. It will bite so hard that the Year 2000 will be discussed in world history textbooks in the Year 3000.
But that's just my opinion. What should you believe? You should believe evidence that shows that individual firms have a big problem in their hands if they are not very close to the first testing stage of their repairs. Social Security began in 1991 to fix a system with 30 million lines of code, employing 400 programmers, and had completed work on 6 million in June, 1996 (CIO MAGAZINE, Sept. 15, 1996). What should we conclude regarding the likelihood that an organization with, say, 20+ million lines of code, will not complete its repairs, preliminary testing, post-test revisions, plus another series of tests, if it began its initial assessment (1% of the task) in 1995? I leave that estimation to you.
What I would like to see is one Fortune 500 firm or one state government anywhere on earth that says, "We are fully Year 2000-compliant today. Our y2k programming staff is now working only on routine maintenance." I keep reading press releases and form letters that say, "We are on schedule," or "we will be ready for testing on December 31, 1998," or "we are making solid progress." What I have yet to read is: "We're all finished."
I also want to see COBOL programmers making as much per hour as corporate lawyers. Most of them make under $50 per hour.
If most repair projects don't get finished, then Western Civlization as we know it is finished. I mention three industries: banks, electricity, and the railroads. If they don't make it, we won't make it.
Put another way, if most mainframe computers in 2000 read 2000 as 1900, then it soon will be 1900, economically speaking. The chaos of millions of people calling a handful of organizations to tell desperate clerks, "You have to rewrite my check," will be sufficient to create a world of continual busy signals, assuming that the phone system stays up. The noise factor is the killer. Systems that depend on computers are not designed to handle huge numbers of exceptions. They will short-circuit.
We're running out of time. I don't mean this or that company, this or that government. I mean the system. (Other categories: "Compliance," "Noncompliant Chips," "Domino Effect.")
Updated - |
Subject
|
03-Jan-97 |
Warning: It Always Takes Longer Than Planned |
13-Jan-97 |
Managers Still Don't Know! |
22-Jan-97 |
Outsource Y2K Repairs? Time Is Growing Short |
04-Mar-97 |
Management Is Asleep at the Wheel: Bankruptcy Ahead |
06-Mar-97 |
If These Organizations Don't Make It, We're in Big Trouble |
11-Mar-97 |
Over 80% of All Software Development Projects Are Late |
19-Mar-97 |
8 Reasons Why Most Non-Compliant Companies Will Not Make It |
25-Mar-97 |
500,000 to 700,000 Additional Experienced Programmers Needed in US |
01-Apr-97 |
The Coming Break-Up of Code Repair Teams -> Bankruptcy |
09-Apr-97 |
1999 Deadline, not 2000: Not Much Time Remaining |
09-Apr-97 |
Fortune 500 Companies Have Not Yet Begun Code Repairs |
27-Apr-97 |
6% Have Begun to Fix Their Code (An Overestimate) |
06-May-97 |
Oklahoma State University: 12 Years, 80% Completion (Pre-Testing) |
17-May-97 |
Most British Firms Have Not Begun Their Repairs |
21-May-97 |
An Extra 1,000,000 Experienced COBOL Programmers Needed |
03-Jun-97 |
One Man + 10,500,000 Lines of Code = Dead Company in 2000 |
10-Jun-97 |
Japan: Way, Way Behind |
10-Jun-97 |
Code Ready for Testing in 1998: A Naive Manager's Dream |
10-Jun-97 |
Japan: The Godzilla of Noncompliance |
18-Jun-97 |
Get Started Fixing It Now! (1997 version) |
18-Jun-97 |
Why We Know They Aren't Fixing It Yet: Programmers' Salaries |
19-Jun-97 |
Expert Says It's Too Late to Revise Existing Code |
20-Jun-97 |
13% of U.S Companies Surveyed Have Launched Y2K Fix |
21-Jun-97 |
Y2K Programmer Says That Managers Are Still in Denial |
24-Jun-97 |
Can 21-Day, Home School COBOL Programmers Fill the Gap? |
24-Jun-97 |
One Company Must Hire 10,000 Programmers |
28-Jun-97 |
2/3 of Organizations Polled Have No Y2K Budget (Spring 1997) |
01-Jul-97 |
We Can't Go Back to Manually Controlled Systems |
09-Jul-97 |
Australia: It May Be Too Late, Says Science Minister |
16-Jul-97 |
95% of the Work Remains to Be Done, Testifies Expert |
17-Jul-97 |
Microcomputer Magazine Says Nobody Knows |
22-Jul-97 |
British Businesses Ignore Y2K |
28-Jul-97 |
British Firms Are Way Behind |
30-Jul-97 |
How to Prove That a Y2K Project Will Not Make It |
30-Jul-97 |
A Programmer Can Correct 100,000 lines Per Year |
06-Aug-97 |
Not Enough Foreign Programmers to Fix the Problem |
12-Aug-97 |
78% of the World's Code Is Outside the U.S. (Capers Jones) |
12-Aug-97 |
35/35 Large Companies: No Y2K Budgets Yet |
10-Sep-97 |
80% of Y2K Repair Firms Have Excess Capacity |
24-Sep-97 |
Top 40 Firm May Be Gone in 2000, Says Its Y2K Repairman |
25-Sep-97 |
Australia's Computer Experts Ignore Y2K |
25-Sep-97 |
30% of Companies Have Not Addressed Y2K -- Gartner |
26-Sep-97 |
Success Formula: Start Your Repair in 1992 or Earlier |
26-Sep-97 |
Y2K News Travels Slowly |
01-Oct-97 |
Half the Computer Divisions Won't Get Extra Money in '98 for Y2K |
02-Oct-97 |
55% of Large French Companies Have Not Begun |
08-Oct-97 |
Only 16% of Fortune 500 Companies Have Begun Their Repairs |
22-Oct-97 |
Novell's Client-Server Problem |
24-Oct-97 |
Britain: Half of Firms Have Done Nothing |
24-Oct-97 |
Silicon Valley: No Help Wanted! |
24-Oct-97 |
Why Not Just Switch to a New Computer? |
24-Oct-97 |
80% of All US Corporations Will Be Compliant in 2000: Gartner |
25-Oct-97 |
Fortune 1000 Can Survive, But Small Firms in Trouble, Experts Say |
25-Oct-97 |
Europe's Top 100 Firms: Not One Is Compliant |
28-Oct-97 |
Britain Could Lose 37% of Its Productivity |
30-Oct-97 |
Britain's "Action 2000" Director Will Work One Day a Week |
30-Oct-97 |
The Illusion of Salvation from Indian Programmers |
01-Nov-97 |
Over 95% of Companies Are Not Compliant, Worldwide |
01-Nov-97 |
Over 75% of Retailers Are Noncompliant |
05-Nov-97 |
Great Britain: 75% of Manufacturers Have No Y2K Strategy |
06-Nov-97 |
U.S. Government Will Hold an International Meeting in 1998 |
08-Nov-97 |
Irish Companies: Almost 50% Have No Y2K Plan |
08-Nov-97 |
50% of All US Organizations Won't Make the Testing Deadline |
08-Nov-97 |
Gartner Group Warns Congress: Not Enough Programmers |
10-Nov-97 |
Software Company Executive Says He'll Be in Gold in 2000 |
13-Nov-97 |
902 British Firms: Confused Awareness, Little Action |
15-Nov-97 |
COBOL Programmers: Tightening Supplies |
17-Nov-97 |
Major Y2K Problem-Solving Seminar Is Cancelled: 3 Attendees |
18-Nov-97 |
Procrastination: Then and Now |
18-Nov-97 |
It's Too Late for 30% of Businesses and Governments (Optimism!) |
19-Nov-97 |
Half of British Firms Plan to Wait Until 1999 to Begin Repairs |
20-Nov-97 |
Programmer Shortage? Hire the Homeless! |
20-Nov-97 |
Purdue: 12 Years, 80% Completion (Pre-Testing) |
25-Nov-97 |
No Doomsayers . . . Just No Provable Good News |
01-Dec-97 |
Not One Software Project on Time in 10 Years: California |
02-Dec-97 |
Panic vs. Ignorance Among New Zealand Executives |
02-Dec-97 |
St. Louis: 60% of Businesses Have Not Begun; 40% Are Unaware |
02-Dec-97 |
Survey Reports Greater Progress (Undefined) |
03-Dec-97 |
A Shortage of U.S. Programmers: 400,000? 500,000? |
04-Dec-97 |
Australia: Over One-Third of Firms Won't Meet the Deadline |
09-Dec-97 |
Half of Canada's Firms Have Not Begun |
11-Dec-97 |
Why Asia Won't Make the Deadline |
11-Dec-97 |
No Program Yet, Say 45% of British Managers |
15-Dec-97 |
Humor: 12 Reasons Not to Worry About Late Date |
27-Dec-97 |
Prediction: One-Third of IT Projects Won't Make It |
29-Dec-97 |
20% of the Largest US Companies have a Y2K Project |
29-Dec-97 |
Less Than 50% of Australian Companies Have a Y2K Project |
29-Dec-97 |
Scary Report in BUSINESS WEEK |
29-Dec-97 |
38% of Irish Senior Managers Have Heard About Y2K |
31-Dec-97 |
Optimism for 1997 in WALL STREET JOURNAL -- 1996 |
31-Dec-97 |
1998: Time to Start Panicking, Says BYTE MAGAZINE |
06-Jan-98 |
One Medium-Size Success; Many Barely Started Projects |
07-Jan-98 |
German Businessmen: Far, Far Behind |
07-Jan-98 |
A Disaster in the Making, Says Robin Guenier |
08-Jan-98 |
Same Old Refrain: "You Had Better Start Now!" |
09-Jan-98 |
British May Use Inmates to Fix Y2K |
10-Jan-98 |
Consultant Says That American Firms Are Dragging Their Feet |
13-Jan-98 |
60% of European Firms Surveyed Are Not Planning Much |
13-Jan-98 |
Australia: Almost 50% of Systems May Fail |
13-Jan-98 |
How Peter de Jager defines "Too Late" |
17-Jan-98 |
2/3 of Big U.S. Businesses Are Still Without Detailed Y2K Plans |
22-Jan-98 |
British Firms Think Y2K Repairs Will Be Cheap, Easy |
23-Jan-98 |
700,000 Extra Programmers Needed in U.S. |
04-Feb-98 |
New Jersey Businesses Say Y2K Is No Big Deal |
04-Feb-98 |
70,000 Midrange IBM Systems May Be Noncompliant |
04-Feb-98 |
PC Journalist Says Y2K Won't Be Much of a Problem |
05-Feb-98 |
Canadian Businesses Are Doing Little |
07-Feb-98 |
Bad News from Management Consultant |
09-Feb-98 |
Public Awareness: More Serious Language |
10-Feb-98 |
$9 Million Y2K Repair Job: Oops! Try Again. $10 Million More, Please! |
10-Feb-98 |
De Jager Warns: Businesses Still Don't Get It |
10-Feb-98 |
We'll Make The Deadline, Say 97% of U.S. Big Businesses |
11-Feb-98 |
Major Y2K Advisory Firms Stop Taking New Clients |
12-Feb-98 |
Yourdon's Warning: Large Programming Projects Suffer Worst |
12-Feb-98 |
STANDISH GROUP Report: Most Programming Projects Are Late |
16-Feb-98 |
Why the Crash Will Happen in 1999 |
16-Feb-98 |
Great Britain: Insufficient Resources to Solve the Problem |
17-Feb-98 |
Canadian Businesses: 10% Have Taken Action |
17-Feb-98 |
Programmer Shortage: British Inmates Kept Out of Y2K Industry |
18-Feb-98 |
Germany: 8% of Firms Have Begun Repairs; 70% Have Done Nothing |
19-Feb-98 |
10% of Australian and European Companies Won't Make Deadline |
21-Feb-98 |
Third World Countries: No Y2K Plans, No Money |
22-Feb-98 |
130 Man Years Per Average Company = Programmer Shortage |
24-Feb-98 |
Florida Hospitals Have Not Begun Repairs |
24-Feb-98 |
Plenty of Capacity Left in Y2K Repair Industry: July, 1997 |
26-Feb-98 |
The Rest of the World Has Barely Begun |
03-Mar-98 |
Corporate Denial in Canada: The Costs Keep Rising |
03-Mar-98 |
Project Completion in Canada: 5% to 30% |
09-Mar-98 |
British Petroleum Promises the Traditional 31 Dec. 1998 Deadline |
10-Mar-98 |
Almost No Programmers to Hire; Therefore, Y2K Can't Be Fixed |
11-Mar-98 |
Vendors' Mainframe Software: 18 Months to Install |
20-Mar-98 |
High Tech Industry is Y2K-Silent. No Leadership |
07-Apr-98 |
Merrill Lynch Identifies Compliant Firms: None |
07-Apr-98 |
Fortune 2000 Firms Decide to Forego Y2K Repairs |
07-Apr-98 |
Gartner Survey: No Hospital Is at the Code Repair Phase |
09-Apr-98 |
25% of Firms and Governments Have Not Begun Y2K Projects |
13-Apr-98 |
60% of Large U.S. Firms Surveyed Have Y2K Projects |
13-Apr-98 |
Germany: 8% of Large Firms Have Y2K Projects |
15-Apr-98 |
Asian Calendars Don't Mention 2000; Hence, Lack of Concern |
15-Apr-98 |
Caspar Weinberger Sounds the Warning: Slow Response |
17-Apr-98 |
Robin Guenier Warns of Disruptions for Britain |
17-Apr-98 |
Systems Are Beginning to Break Down |
21-Apr-98 |
General Motors: Too Little, Too Late |
23-Apr-98 |
A Detailed Contingency Plan: Very Complex, Highly Unlikely |
23-Apr-98 |
60% of Large U.S. Firms Have Completed Assessment Stage |
24-Apr-98 |
No Y2K Progress for 50% of European Businesses; Panic Looms |
24-Apr-98 |
Asia Is Far Behind |
29-Apr-98 |
78% of Australia's Small Businesses Have Not Begun |
30-Apr-98 |
Swiss Firms Are Nowhere Near Compliance |
01-May-98 |
The Little Engine That Could Needed Tracks |
01-May-98 |
Only 10% of U.S. Businesses Have Completed Half the Remediation |
06-May-98 |
Doomsday Scenarios Summarized in Major Technology Publication |
07-May-98 |
Y2K Forums - MirrorModerator Skousen Makes It into Forbes |
07-May-98 |
If They are All Working on It, Where Are the Want Ads? |
08-May-98 |
Britain's Robin Guenier Says It's Too Late: Contingency Plans Needed |
12-May-98 |
Technology Association President Says Society Is At Risk |
12-May-98 |
Denial: Singapore, 1940; The West, 1998 |
12-May-98 |
Titanic Is Sinking, But There's Still Time, Says Prudential |
14-May-98 |
U.S. Government to Launch an Awareness Campaign |
18-May-98 |
Buildings May Shut Down on Sept. 9, 1999 |
18-May-98 |
Hardly Any U.S. Firms Are Submitting Cost Estimates to the S.E.C. |
18-May-98 |
Budgets Tell All: The U.S. Won't Make the Deadline |
19-May-98 |
Small Businesses Ignore Y2K |
19-May-98 |
70% of Computers in U.S. Still Haven't Been Checked for Y2K |
22-May-98 |
30% of Y2K Money Budgeted Has Been Spent in U.S. |
23-May-98 |
Cost Per Line of Code: $6.46, Says Gartner Group |
23-May-98 |
Too Late to Start, Says Y2K Specialist |
25-May-98 |
Old Good News Is Bad News: The ITAA Index |
26-May-98 |
Cost Per Line of Code: Maybe $4, Says Kappelman |
27-May-98 |
75% of Nations Have Done Nothing, Y2K Czar Estimates |
29-May-98 |
75% of Small Business Have Done Nothing on Y2K -- Gallup |
31-May-98 |
70% of Canada's Busineses Have Done Nothing |
02-Jun-98 |
75% of U.S. Small Businesses Have Not Addressed Y2K |
04-Jun-98 |
The 90% Syndrome: Why Projects Seem to be on Target |
08-Jun-98 |
Russian Government Begins Inventory |
08-Jun-98 |
Asian Nations Are Far Behind |
08-Jun-98 |
Senior Programmers Get $7,500/Day, Plus Flights Home |
12-Jun-98 |
Jim Seymour: Performing Triage Is Painful but Necessary |
12-Jun-98 |
Canada: Behind in Every Y2K Area |
13-Jun-98 |
Fortune 500 Companies Have Done Just About Nothing |
15-Jun-98 |
Corporate America: Almost Nothing Has Been Done |
17-Oct-98 |
Alan Simpson, Former Y2K Alarmist, Now Switches
|
17-Oct-98 |
Why Y2K Awareness Was Always a Doomed Program
|
17-Oct-98 |
10% of Computer Executives Surveyed Are Stockpiling Food
|
19-Oct-98 |
Rural Living Described: Good Summary
|
19-Oct-98 |
My Response to Harry Browne's Three Lies
|
22-Oct-98 |
Maine Power Company Abandons 12/31/98 Deadline
|
23-Oct-98 |
Defining Fear Mongering: Saying Something Can't Be Fixed
|
27-Oct-98 |
Y2K Repair Estimates More Than Double in New Zealand
|
28-Oct-98 |
Senior Computer Experts Warn of Major Crisis in Great Britain
|
28-Oct-98 |
Japan Set Up an Action Plan in September
|
02-Nov-98 |
The Revenge of the Didn't Get Its
|
02-Nov-98 |
Six Months to a Y2K Fix or Threat of Bankruptcy
|
03-Nov-98 |
A Tremendous Site: Links to Sites on on Personal Preparation
|
04-Nov-98 |
Firms Begin to Miss Y2K Repair Deadlines
|
04-Nov-98 |
Walton Feed: Pick Up Your Food Next April
|
11-Nov-98 |
Hong Kong Economy: Y2K Recession Warning
|
11-Nov-98 |
Euro Story: As If It's Not Already Dead on Arrival
|
11-Nov-98 |
A Day Late and a Dollar Short: Will This Be You?
|
11-Nov-98 |
Corporate Budgets Tell the Truth: A Missed Deadline
|
13-Nov-98 |
ABC News Runs a Brief, Pessimistic Report
|
18-Nov-98 |
Water Utilities Survey Reports Extremely Bad News and Very Good News. How's That Again?
|
21-Nov-98 |
Six Y2K Mistakes That Organizations Are Making
|
23-Nov-98 |
It Seems That I'm a Nut.
|
25-Nov-98 |
Japanese Government Admits to a Major Problem
|
30-Nov-98 |
Hiring Welfare Recipients to Solve Y2K
|
02-Dec-98 |
Mormon Canneries and Sales Taxes
|
08-Dec-98 |
Writer Warns that the December 31 Deadline Promise Will Backfire
|
09-Dec-98 |
10 Large Firms Whose Y2K Tab Has Risen
|
09-Dec-98 |
Yardeni Calculates Y2K Budgets: Laggards Everywhere
|
18-Dec-98 |
Supposedly Fixed Systems Turn Out to Be Error-Filled
|
19-Dec-98 |
April, 1999: Foretaste of Year 2000
|
22-Dec-98 |
The Fools vs. the FUDs
|
23-Dec-98 |
At Least 31 Nations Have Y2K Web Sites
|
02-Jan-99 |
From Corporate Deferral to Corporate Defeat
|
02-Jan-99 |
Kiss Chicago Goodbye
|
04-Jan-99 |
How Major Nations Compare: Gartner Group Study
|
20-Jan-99 |
Many of the Largest British Firms Haven't Completed Inventory
|
22-Jan-99 |
Euro Conversion Gobbled Up Programming Resources in Europe
|
23-Jan-99 |
GAO Report to Congress: Water Systems Are at Risk
|
23-Jan-99 |
Schedules Fall Apart
|
23-Jan-99 |
45% of Britain's Largest Firms Are Behind Schedule
|
01-Feb-99 |
The Supermarket Compliance Deadline Billboard that Died
|
04-Feb-99 |
Death in a Cottage Industry
|
12-Feb-99 |
Cummins Forgets to Update Its Y2K Page: Still Promises 1998 Compliance
|
23-Feb-99 |
40% Of Australian Companies Have Done Nothing
|
25-Feb-99 |
30% of Australian Businesses Work to Fix Y2K
|
27-Feb-99 |
USAA Insurance Is Not Compliant Yet: 1994-1999
|
09-Mar-99 |
Organizations Should Be in the Testing Stage Now
|
15-Mar-99 |
March: The Month of the Missed Deadlines
|
17-Mar-99 |
Wired Publishes 4 Terrifying Articles on Y2K
|
18-Mar-99 |
Doomsday Fudged: British Skeptic Thinks Y2K Optimism Is Premature
|
19-Mar-99 |
Japan Seeks to Save Face; Needs to Save Time
|
23-Mar-99 |
50% of Korea's Small and Medium Size Businesses Have Not Begun
|
24-Mar-99 |
What Ever Happened to Triage?
|
24-Mar-99 |
EDS: Still Not Compliant
|
29-Mar-99 |
British Employers Refuse to Hire 90-Day COBOL Wonders
|
29-Mar-99 |
Y2K-Related Dates, 1998-2001
|
29-Mar-99 |
25% of U.S. Insurance Companies Are Behind, Says Optimistic Weiss
|
02-Apr-99 |
U.S. Has Spent One-Quarter of the Money It Should Spend -- Boivin
|
02-Apr-99 |
Australia's Y2K Repair Cost Estimate Rises 60% in One Month
|
03-Apr-99 |
China Got Started Too Late, Has Little Money for Y2K Repairs
|
03-Apr-99 |
Capers Jones' Plan Ahead Service's Pesss Release: May 5, 1998
|
09-Apr-99 |
When It's Too Late to Install a New System, What Then?
|
15-Apr-99 |
Food Industry Group May Create a Y2K Data Base
|
19-Apr-99 |
The 15 Showcase Y2K Awareness Firms in Great Britain Turn Out to Be Noncompliant
|